yusker

Best Pizza in Ancaster

6 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.

Updated September 2026

#1

The answer

Brassie Pub

4.5(1,085 reviews)$$

Rollicking tavern serving American and British bites with draught beer and wood-fired charm

See the full profile

  1. 🍽️
    #2

    Joe's pizza Ancaster

    4.2(328 reviews)

    Neighbourhood pizza spot where families gather for classic pies and familiar flavours

  2. 🍽️
    #3

    Ancaster Pizza

    4.0(226 reviews)

    Neighbourhood pizza spot drawing Ancaster locals for casual gatherings

  3. 🍽️
    #4

    Gino's Pizza

    4.1(194 reviews)

    Classic pizzas that keep Ancaster families coming back for another slice

  4. 🍽️
    #5

    Pizza Pizza

    3.7(238 reviews)

    Quick pizza slices and whole pies for Ancaster locals on the go

  5. Pane Fresco#6

    Pane Fresco

    4.2(18 reviews)

    Wood-fired pizza and Italian comfort food in the heart of Ancaster

More in Ancaster

Best cafésBest restaurants

Best pizza in other cities

TorontoCalgaryEdmontonMississaugaBramptonScarboroughNorth YorkWinnipegEtobicokeMontréal

Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.