Best Pizza in Buffalo

4.4(1,253 reviews)

Classic New York–style slices in a casual neighborhood spot beloved by Buffalo locals

4.5(886 reviews)

Wood-fired pies and Italian comfort in a neighbourhood spot locals keep coming back to

4.2(1,156 reviews)

Neighborhood pizzeria serving up hearty pies with a welcoming, casual vibe

3.9(1,303 reviews)

Neighborhood pizza joint drawing steady crowds with classic pies and casual vibes

4.7(364 reviews)

Craft pizza made with care — locals' pick for a quality slice in Buffalo

3.8(1,323 reviews)

No-frills pizza and wings when you need them, a familiar standby for Buffalo crowds

4.3(560 reviews)

Classic New York-style pies made with care in the heart of Elmwood

4.4(437 reviews)

Buffalo pizza pub with a sports-bar vibe and solid neighborhood following

4.0(788 reviews)

Wood-fired pies and Italian pub fare steps from the waterfront

4.4(407 reviews)

Beloved Buffalo pizza joint serving crispy pies with generous toppings

4.3(466 reviews)

Wood-fired pies and shareable plates that turn any night into a neighborhood gathering

4.1(279 reviews)

Thin-crust pies and neighborhood warmth drawing Buffalo locals back for more

4.1(211 reviews)

Dependable slices and whole pies that keep Buffalo locals coming back

3.5(144 reviews)

Familiar pizza chain serving thick-crust pies and sides in a casual counter-serve setup