Best Pizza in Hamilton
40 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
#1East Side Mario's
$$4.5(4,772 reviews)
Family-friendly Italian-American chain with hearty pasta, pizza and comfort classics
- 🍽️#2
Maipai
$$4.8(1,678 reviews)
Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas draw crowds to this welcoming Hamilton spot
- 🍽️#3
Hamilton Dabbawala
4.5(2,715 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and Indian-inspired flavours that draw crowds from across town
#4Pizza Fiamma Hamilton
4.7(1,798 reviews)
Neapolitan pizzas with charred crusts that keep Hamilton coming back for more
#5Chicago Style Pizza
$$4.5(2,501 reviews)
Warm casual spot for Chicago deep-dish pies, pasta, subs and a neighbourhood buzz
- 🍽️#6
Bardō Locke St. Hamilton
$$4.5(2,399 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and craft cocktails draw crowds to this lively Locke St spot
- 🍽️#7
Tony G’s Pizzeria
4.8(1,319 reviews)
Hand-tossed pies with proper char, drawing crowds who know their pizza
#8Cowabunga+
$$4.5(1,974 reviews)
Wood-fired pizza drawing crowds who value quality dough and bold toppings
#9Cafe Baffico - Sourdough Doughnuts + Pizza
4.8(1,101 reviews)
Neapolitan pizza and sourdough doughnuts drawing crowds to Hamilton's pizza scene
- 🍽️#10
Timmy's Tanür
4.6(1,262 reviews)
Wood-fired pizza in Hamilton where quality ingredients meet neighbourhood warmth
#11Shorty's Pizza
$$4.4(1,434 reviews)
Thin-crust pizza and casual Italian eats that keep Hamilton coming back for more
- 🍽️#12
Domino's Pizza
$4.3(1,598 reviews)
Quick delivery and carryout pizzas with classic toppings and sides
#13Mario's Pizza and Wings
$4.6(983 reviews)
Simple family-run spot where pies and wings keep locals coming back
- 🍽️#14
Zehra Turkish Cuisine
4.8(697 reviews)
Authentic Turkish flavours drawing crowds to Hamilton for pide, kebabs and baklava
#15Boston Pizza
$$4.2(1,734 reviews)
Family-friendly chain serving pizza, pasta and wings in a casual sports-bar setting
- 🍽️#16
Sasso Pizza Market & Bar
$$4.4(1,090 reviews)
Creative artisan pizzas and seasonal pub eats in upbeat, modern surroundings
#17Valentino's Restaurant - Westdale
$$4.4(1,032 reviews)
Classic pizza spot where Hamilton families and friends gather for warm pies
#18Pizza Bell & Wings
$4.2(1,285 reviews)
Casual pizza and wings spot where Hamilton locals come to eat and hang out
#19DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta - Hamilton (Main St)
$4.1(1,398 reviews)
Build-your-own pizzas fired to order, plus fresh pastas in a casual, buzzing spot
- 🍽️#20
Lava Pizza & Wings
$4.0(1,605 reviews)
Chain spot for specialty pizzas, wings and fried bites — quick takeout locals rely on
#21Mr Singh’s Pizza Hamilton
4.4(781 reviews)
Indian-inspired pizza bringing bold spice and creative toppings to Hamilton
#22Lê Bella Pizza (Bella Pizza)
$4.4(762 reviews)
No-nonsense pizzas with loads of options, a local go-to for quick online orders
#23Mr. Grande Pizza
$$4.4(659 reviews)
Basic take-out spot locals rely on for custom-topped pizzas, wings and subs
#24Mountain Pizza and Wings
4.8(346 reviews)
Locals pile in for crispy wings and proper pizza with zero fuss
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.