Best Pizza in New York
13 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
#1Joe's Pizza Broadway
4.4(25,667 reviews)
Classic New York slices drawing crowds daily for that iconic thin crust
- 🍽️#2
NY Pizza Suprema
4.6(8,599 reviews)
Corner slice joint that's fed theatre crowds and locals for decades
#3John's of Bleecker Street
4.6(8,306 reviews)
#4Rubirosa
4.6(7,197 reviews)
Beloved Nolita spot where thin-crust pies and classic Italian cooking draw steady crowds
#5Joe's Pizza
4.4(10,332 reviews)
Classic New York slices loved by generations of locals and tourists alike
- 🍽️#6
Prince Street Pizza
4.4(9,060 reviews)
Thick-cut Sicilian squares beloved by downtown crowds and pizza purists alike
#7Bleecker Street Pizza
4.5(6,368 reviews)
Crispy thin-crust slices that New Yorkers queue for on a Greenwich Village corner
#8L’industrie Pizzeria - West Village
4.7(3,435 reviews)
Crispy-thin crusts and late-night energy that keeps West Village locals coming back
#9Scarr's Pizza
4.4(4,736 reviews)
Sourdough pies and a cult following in the Lower East Side
#10Eataly
4.2(6,388 reviews)
Sprawling Italian marketplace with wood-fired pizza, pasta counters and buzzing crowds
- 🍽️#11
Emily
4.5(3,544 reviews)
Wood-fired pies with a cult following in a cozy West Village setting
- 🍽️#12
Mama's TOO! Pizzeria West Village
4.3(1,831 reviews)
Square pies with crispy, focaccia-like crusts that earned a devoted West Village following
- 🍽️#13
Ceres
4.1(1,000 reviews)
Wood-fired Roman-style pizza drawing crowds for crisp, airy slices
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.