Best Pizza in St. John's
15 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
#1Piatto Pizzeria + Enoteca Downtown
4.7(1,138 reviews)
Neapolitan-style pizzas and Italian small plates that bring crowds back nightly
#2Piatto Pizzeria + Enoteca
4.5(1,207 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and house-made pastas in a warm downtown trattoria
#3Black Cat Pizza
4.9(625 reviews)
Wood-fired Neapolitan pies and a buzzing neighbourhood vibe that draws the whole city
- 🍽️#4
Boston Pizza
4.2(879 reviews)
Reliable pizza, wings and pasta that St. John's families turn to on busy nights
- 🍽️#5
Domino's Pizza
4.3(570 reviews)
Chain pizza with reliable delivery when cravings strike in St. John's
#6Donati's Pizza
4.2(384 reviews)
Familiar pizza spot serving pies and comfort staples in St. John's
#7Venice Pizzeria
4.1(409 reviews)
Classic pizzeria where St. John's gathers for reliably satisfying pies
#8No Name Pizza
3.9(546 reviews)
Wood-fired pies and casual vibes that locals count on for an easy dinner
#9Pennywell Convenience
4.4(169 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza spot loved by locals for friendly service and hot, cheesy pies
- 🍽️#10
Old Town Pizza
4.1(198 reviews)
Classic pizzeria serving St. John's with dependable pies and familiar comfort
- 🍽️#11
Peter's Pizza
3.9(214 reviews)
Classic pizza joint drawing locals for dependable pies and a laid-back vibe
- 🍽️#12
Pizza Empire
4.0(148 reviews)
Reliable pizza joint drawing steady crowds in the heart of St. John's
- 🍽️#13
Peter's Pizza and Golden Foods
3.7(191 reviews)
No-frills neighbourhood spot for pizza and comfort classics
- 🍽️#14
Pizza Hut
4.0(106 reviews)
Familiar pizza and sides that locals trust for a no-fuss meal
#15Greco Pizza
4.1(82 reviews)
Straightforward pizza locals count on for delivery or takeout
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.