Best Pizza in St Thomas
11 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
The answer
Pizzaworx
4.7(778 reviews)
Wood-fired pizza that locals return to again and again
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
Boston Pizza
$$4.2(1,121 reviews)
Casual chain favourite for pizza, pasta, wings and catching the game
- 🍽️#3
Domino's Pizza
4.7(432 reviews)
Reliable pizza spot delivering hot, cheesy comfort to St Thomas locals
- 🍽️#4
Al's Pizzeria
$4.3(446 reviews)
Straightforward pies that keep St Thomas coming back for slices
#5Pizza Tonite St Thomas
$$4.1(489 reviews)
Dependable pizzas drawing regulars for classic pies and easy pickup
- 🍽️#6
Gino's Pizza
4.6(205 reviews)
Classic pizza that keeps St Thomas locals coming back for more
#7Red Swan Pizza - St. Thomas
4.2(274 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza spot dishing out crispy pies that keep locals coming back
- 🍽️#8
Pizza Hut
$$3.7(410 reviews)
Chain pizzeria with wings and pasta for dine-in or delivery
- 🍽️#9
Pizza Pizza
4.1(163 reviews)
Reliable pizza joint that St Thomas families return to for quick, satisfying pies
- 🍽️#10
Little Caesars Pizza
$3.1(344 reviews)
Housemade dough tossed fresh, wings and signature breadsticks on the side
#11ST Thomas Pizza and Wings
4.4(24 reviews)
Crispy wings and quality pizza made with care in the heart of St Thomas
More in St Thomas
Best pizza in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.