yusker

Best Pizza in Tampa

17 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.

Updated September 2026

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza#1

The answer

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

4.6(7,943 reviews)

New York-style slices drawing regulars for that crispy-chewy crust and no-fuss vibe

See the full profile

  1. Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar#2

    Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

    4.7(3,751 reviews)

    Wood-fired pies and fresh pasta that keep Tampa coming back for more

  2. 🍽️
    #3

    New York New York Pizza

    4.5(3,049 reviews)

    Classic New York-style slices drawing crowds who crave that thin, foldable crust

  3. WingHouse Bar & Grill - Tampa Stadium#4

    WingHouse Bar & Grill - Tampa Stadium

    4.2(4,006 reviews)

    Wings, pizza and game-day energy near the stadium

  4. Water + Flour#5

    Water + Flour

    4.6(1,681 reviews)

    Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas that draw crowds from across Tampa

  5. Fabrica Pizza#6

    Fabrica Pizza

    4.6(1,367 reviews)

    Wood-fired Neapolitan pies that bring Tampa crowds together nightly

  6. 🍽️
    #7

    Tampa Pizza Company Downtown

    4.3(2,213 reviews)

    Hand-stretched dough and quality toppings that keep downtown regulars coming back

  7. Forbici Modern Italian#8

    Forbici Modern Italian

    4.4(1,816 reviews)

    Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas and Italian classics in a relaxed, welcoming setting

  8. Santoro's Pizzeria#9

    Santoro's Pizzeria

    4.5(1,460 reviews)

    Thick-crust pies and generous portions keeping Tampa families coming back

  9. Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria#10

    Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

    4.4(1,515 reviews)

    Hand-tossed Neapolitan pies and fresh pasta, crafted with care

  10. 🍽️
    #11

    HAVANA 86 - Authentic Cuban Flavor

    4.2(2,111 reviews)

    Authentic Cuban flavors served fast in the heart of Tampa

  11. Flippers Pizza Co. - South Tampa#12

    Flippers Pizza Co. - South Tampa

    4.8(764 reviews)

    Crispy-crusted pies that keep South Tampa coming back for more

  12. 3 Corners Pizza#13

    3 Corners Pizza

    4.4(828 reviews)

    Crispy pies and neighborhood buzz in a Tampa favorite that locals keep coming back to

  13. Ava Tampa#14

    Ava Tampa

    4.0(1,067 reviews)

    Wood-fired pizzas and Italian classics that bring neighbors back week after week

  14. 🍽️
    #15

    Jay Luigi

    4.6(415 reviews)

    Neighborhood pizza spot loved by locals for its crisp pies and casual vibe

  15. 🍽️
    #16

    Flexx Sports Bar & Ultra Lounge

    4.4(426 reviews)

    Pizza and game-day vibes with a lounge feel that keeps locals coming back

  16. Colony Grill - Tampa Midtown#17

    Colony Grill - Tampa Midtown

    4.5(347 reviews)

    Thin-crust tavern pies and cold beer in a lively, no-fuss setting

Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.