Best Pizza in Thunder Bay
14 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
The answer
Boston Pizza
4.1(1,237 reviews)
Familiar chain serving crowd-pleasing pizza and wings in a relaxed sports-bar setting
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
Domino's Pizza
4.3(634 reviews)
Late-night pizza that arrives hot when you need it most
- 🍽️#3
Pizza Pizza
4.0(599 reviews)
Late-night slices and familiar pies in a reliable local chain
- 🍽️#4
NYS
4.8(182 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas that keep Thunder Bay regulars coming back for more
#5Red Swan Pizza
4.6(195 reviews)
Thin-crust pizzas and a warm neighbourhood vibe that keeps Thunder Bay coming back
- 🍽️#6
Pizza Hut
4.0(394 reviews)
Casual pizza chain serving familiar pies and sides in a relaxed setting
#7Lento Wood Fired Pizza
4.9(85 reviews)
Wood-fired pies drawing devoted regulars in Thunder Bay
- 🍽️#8
The Pizza Street
3.9(206 reviews)
Straightforward pizza spot serving slices and pies to Thunder Bay locals
#9Golden Bakery & Pizza
3.7(213 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza and bakery serving Thunder Bay with straightforward comfort
- 🍽️#10
Mama Alfa's Pizzeria
4.1(125 reviews)
Wood-fired pies made with care in a casual Thunder Bay spot
- 🍽️#11
Gino's Pizza
3.6(238 reviews)
Classic pizza joint serving Thunder Bay families for decades
- 🍽️#12
Little Caesars Pizza
3.6(140 reviews)
Quick hot-and-ready pizza when you need an easy, affordable meal
- 🍽️#13
Arnikko's Pizzeria
4.2(58 reviews)
Casual pizzeria where Thunder Bay locals gather for familiar pies and easy company
- 🍽️#14
Papa Johns Pizza
3.4(118 reviews)
Familiar pizza chain serving classic pies and sides for takeout or delivery
More in Thunder Bay
Best pizza in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.