Best Pizza in York
24 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
The answer
Pizza Pizza
4.7(2,052 reviews)
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
244 Pizza & Wings
4.2(1,262 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza and wings joint that keeps York coming back for more
- 🍽️#3
Aleeza's Pizza
4.6(611 reviews)
#4North of Brooklyn Pizzeria
4.4(814 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and a buzzing vibe that brings York locals back again and again
- 🍽️#5
Pizza Hut
4.5(670 reviews)
#6Domino's Pizza
4.4(725 reviews)
Reliable pizza delivery and takeaway popular with York locals craving a quick bite
- 🍽️#7
Halal Kebab Pizza
4.3(411 reviews)
- 🍽️#8
Red Swan Pizza - Toronto Jane St.
4.6(248 reviews)
- 🍽️#9
Oakwood Pizzeria
4.4(306 reviews)
- 🍽️#10
Papa Johns Pizza
4.2(348 reviews)
- 🍽️#11
Chito's Pizza - Mediterranean Restaurant Eglinton
4.4(251 reviews)
- 🍽️#12
El Nour Halal Pizza & Chicken
4.3(265 reviews)
- 🍽️#13
1 Plus 1 Pizza Inc
4.3(264 reviews)
- 🍽️#14
Little Caesars Pizza
3.8(449 reviews)
- 🍽️#15
Jane Pizza and Wings (Jane St.)
4.1(270 reviews)
- 🍽️#16
Metro Pizza & Chicken
4.3(190 reviews)
- 🍽️#17
Pizza Alps
4.0(256 reviews)
- 🍽️#18
Pizza Tazza
4.4(153 reviews)
- 🍽️#19
Pazza Pazza
4.3(142 reviews)
- 🍽️#20
Pizza Nova
3.9(206 reviews)
- 🍽️#21
DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta - Eglinton
4.1(133 reviews)
- 🍽️#22
Pizzaiolo
3.6(256 reviews)
- 🍽️#23
241 Pizza
4.0(104 reviews)
- 🍽️#24
Panzerotto Pizza
3.7(3 reviews)
Best pizza in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.