Best Cafés in Newmarket
79 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
The answer
Paeez Fine Foods
4.9(8,323 reviews)
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
Sweet Aroma
4.9(802 reviews)
#3Metropolis Mercantile + Café
4.7(867 reviews)
Neighbourhood café serving fresh baked goods and coffee in Newmarket
- 🍽️#4
Vince's Market
4.4(989 reviews)
- 🍽️#5
The Maids Cottage
4.7(617 reviews)
- 🍽️#6
Flame Cafe
4.8(506 reviews)
- 🍽️#7
Ice Babo
4.8(504 reviews)
- 🍽️#8
Noon o Alef
4.9(379 reviews)
#9Starbucks Coffee Company
4.3(792 reviews)
Familiar coffee and pastries in a spacious, reliable setting
- 🍽️#10
Baker's Crush
4.8(342 reviews)
- 🍽️#11
Nutmeg Bakeshop
4.8(324 reviews)
- 🍽️#12
Brew It Coffee Bar
4.7(352 reviews)
- 🍽️#13
Mercato on Main
4.4(491 reviews)
#14Tim Hortons
3.8(1,213 reviews)
Canadian coffee chain serving quick comfort and familiar favourites all day
- 🍽️#15
Second Cup Café
4.4(389 reviews)
- 🍽️#16
Pinochio Cafe, Dessert and Ice Cream
4.7(249 reviews)
Charming local cafe serving sweet treats that draw regulars from across town
- 🍽️#17
My Indie Coffee Roasters
4.9(194 reviews)
- 🍽️#18
Paris Baguette
4.2(452 reviews)
Korean-French bakery cafe turning out fluffy pastries and picture-perfect cakes
- 🍽️#19
CoCo Bubble Tea - Newmarket
4.6(249 reviews)
- 🍽️#20
The Funnery
4.4(318 reviews)
- 🍽️#21
Bene Bene Waffle & Ice Cream
4.3(350 reviews)
- 🍽️#22
Cocoa40 Inc.
4.7(172 reviews)
- 🍽️#23
Pichak café
4.9(130 reviews)
- 🍽️#24
The Fresh Tea Shop
4.1(339 reviews)
More in Newmarket
Best cafés in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.