Best Pizza in Newmarket
12 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
- 🍽️#1
Pizzaiolo
4.7(601 reviews)
Wood-fired pizza pulling in the crowds with simple, quality ingredients
#2Let's Be Frank Italian Eatery
4.4(857 reviews)
Neighbourhood Italian where wood-fired pizzas and handmade pastas keep locals coming back
#3Papa Johns Pizza
4.5(584 reviews)
Reliable pizza chain delivering familiar favourites to Newmarket locals
- 🍽️#4
Boston Pizza
4.0(1,227 reviews)
Crowd-pleasing pizzas and pub fare that bring locals back
#5Pizza Pizza
4.2(837 reviews)
Reliable pizza spot locals turn to when the craving hits
#6Il Bistro Cafe & Pizzeria
4.7(357 reviews)
Crispy thin-crust pizza that brings Newmarket locals back again and again
- 🍽️#7
Domino's Pizza
4.2(656 reviews)
Reliable pizza chain delivering quick meals and familiar favourites
- 🍽️#8
Little Caesars Pizza
4.2(310 reviews)
Hot-and-ready pies that locals rely on for fast, no-fuss pizza
#9Pizza Nova
4.1(281 reviews)
Reliable pizzeria keeping Newmarket locals coming back for straightforward pies
#10DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & Pasta - Newmarket
4.3(189 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and pasta in a casual neighbourhood spot
- 🍽️#11
Pizza Hut
3.5(375 reviews)
Classic chain pizza and sides for a casual family meal
- 🍽️#12
Topper's Pizza — Newmarket
3.9(182 reviews)
Reliable neighbourhood pizzeria that locals turn to when cravings hit
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.