Best Pizza in St. Catharines
13 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
The answer
Rollin' Pizza - Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta
4.7(1,134 reviews)
Handcrafted pizzas and pastas that draw crowds in St. Catharines
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
Cafe Amore
4.5(1,369 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza spot locals count on for no-fuss pies and reliable comfort
- 🍽️#3
Boston Pizza
4.3(1,391 reviews)
Casual chain serving pizza, pasta and wings in a family-friendly setting
- 🍽️#4
Pizza Pizza
4.6(822 reviews)
Reliable pizza spot beloved by St. Catharines locals for quick, satisfying slices
#5Paesano Pizza
4.6(770 reviews)
Wood-fired Neapolitan pies that keep St. Catharines coming back for more
#6Pie Guys Tap And Grill
4.3(935 reviews)
Casual pizza spot where St. Catharines gathers for pies, brews and good times
- 🍽️#7
Domino's Pizza
4.3(816 reviews)
Quick-fire pizzas when you need them, trusted by locals across St. Catharines
- 🍽️#8
Fat Cat's Pizza Inc.
4.3(739 reviews)
Cheesy, crispy pies drawing crowds to St. Catharines for no-fuss comfort
- 🍽️#9
The Tangerine Tortoise
4.9(293 reviews)
Wood-fired pizza that keeps St. Catharines coming back for more
- 🍽️#10
Di’s Pizza Pies
4.7(297 reviews)
Neighbourhood pizza spot loved by St. Catharines locals for consistently good pies
#11St. Catharines Pizza Company
4.5(310 reviews)
Crispy crusts and generous toppings keep locals coming back for more
#12Industria Pizzeria + Bar
4.0(575 reviews)
Wood-fired pizzas and Italian comfort in a warm, neighbourhood setting
- 🍽️#13
Pizza Hut
3.6(568 reviews)
Familiar pizza chain serving classic pies, pasta and wings for takeout or delivery
More in St. Catharines
Best pizza in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.