Best Restaurants in St. Catharines
27 spots, ranked by real community signals — photos, ratings and honest verdicts. We never sell placement.
Updated September 2026
#1The answer
Mandarin St. Catharines
4.7(8,672 reviews)
All-you-can-eat Chinese buffet that's become a St. Catharines tradition
See the full profile
- 🍽️#2
Shelby's Legendary Shawarma
4.8(6,884 reviews)
Flavourful shawarma that's earned a cult following across the Niagara region
#3Jack Astor's Bar & Grill St Catharines
4.6(3,846 reviews)
Spirited neighbourhood grill with crowd-pleasing plates and a lively vibe
#4George's Greek Village
4.6(3,695 reviews)
Traditional Greek fare drawing crowds for generous plates and warm hospitality
- 🍽️#5
East Izakaya
4.6(3,187 reviews)
Japanese comfort done right, with fresh sushi and grilled skewers locals return for
#6The Keg Steakhouse + Bar - St. Catharines
4.5(3,352 reviews)
Perfectly grilled steaks and a warm, reliable vibe that keeps crowds coming back
- 🍽️#7
Kelseys Original Roadhouse
4.6(2,713 reviews)
Casual roadhouse comfort where St. Catharines comes for familiar grills and good times
- 🍽️#8
Wind Japanese and Thai
4.6(2,540 reviews)
Beloved local spot serving fresh sushi and Thai staples in a welcoming setting
- 🍽️#9
MA Chinese Cuisine
4.6(2,207 reviews)
Generous portions of Cantonese classics that keep St. Catharines coming back
- 🍽️#10
The Merchant Ale House
4.6(2,041 reviews)
Elevated pub fare and craft brews in a warm, brick-lined space beloved by locals
#11Chile & Agave Mexican Grill
4.4(2,607 reviews)
Vibrant Mexican spot where locals gather for bold flavours and good times
- 🍽️#12
Cat's Caboose
4.4(2,520 reviews)
Casual comfort spot with a loyal following for hearty portions and friendly service
- 🍽️#13
Bugsy's
4.5(1,949 reviews)
Casual comfort food that brings friends and family together in St. Catharines
- 🍽️#14
Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill
4.2(2,895 reviews)
Comfort-driven Italian favourites that keep St. Catharines coming back
#15Sultan's Mediterranean Grill- St. Catharines
4.7(1,198 reviews)
Generous Mediterranean plates that keep St. Catharines coming back for more
- 🍽️#16
The Twisted Pig | Italian Kitchen
4.5(1,574 reviews)
Handcrafted Italian comfort that keeps St. Catharines coming back
#17Fairview Mall
3.9(3,611 reviews)
St. Catharines shopping hub with diverse dining options and family-friendly spots
- 🍽️#18
The Feathery Pub
4.4(1,159 reviews)
Casual neighbourhood spot for comfort plates and a laid-back pint
- 🍽️#19
Fat Rabbit
4.6(740 reviews)
Modern comfort food in a cozy spot locals gather for generous portions and warmth
#20Chuck's Roadhouse Bar & Grill
4.0(1,892 reviews)
Casual roadhouse vibe with comfort fare that brings friends and families together
#21Sushi Paradise
4.1(1,296 reviews)
Fresh sushi rolls and bento boxes locals return to for quick, satisfying Japanese eats
- 🍽️#22
Romby's Tavern & Smokehouse
4.4(745 reviews)
Hearty smokehouse with generous portions and a welcoming neighbourhood vibe
#23Kully's Original Sports Bar
4.3(832 reviews)
Casual sports bar with classic pub fare and a welcoming neighbourhood vibe
- 🍽️#24
Sala Sixty One (61) Bar + Social
4.4(349 reviews)
Elevated comfort plates and craft cocktails in a buzzy, social downtown setting
More in St. Catharines
Best restaurants in other cities
Rankings on Yusker come from real-world signals and community sentiment — venues can never pay for position. Want these answers with your location, cravings and friends’ takes built in? Get the Yusker app.